

Artist · 1911–1961
Hy Hirsh
American
San Francisco, USA · Paris, France
Hy Hirsh (1911–1961) was an American photographer, experimental filmmaker, and visual music artist. Circa 1950, he began translating electronic oscilloscope patterns onto film with vibrant colors, producing the earliest surviving oscilloscope-based artworks.
In the collection
3 works
Born in Philadelphia in 1911 to Russian immigrant parents, Hyman "Hy" Hirsh moved with them to Southern California. By age 19, he was working as a camera operator and editor for Columbia Studios in Hollywood (1930-36) while also pursuing his artistic still photography. His early 1930s portfolio combined compositions influenced by Group f64 (razor-sharp focus) with social documentary themes depicting urban decay and industrial debris for the Works Progress Administration (WPA). These early works earned him a place alongside photographers like Ansel Adams and Edward Weston in major California exhibitions.
In 1937, Hirsh relocated to San Francisco, taking a job as staff photographer for the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco. Behind locked lab doors, he secretly used the museum darkrooms to experiment with non-traditional photographic techniques. He constructed double exposures, multi-layered color compositions, and abstract moving images.
Hirsh became a pioneer in using cathode-ray-tube oscilloscopes for fine art. He devised a custom setup to record electronic waveform patterns off an oscilloscope screen in black-and-white, then used color filters and a hand-built optical printer to layer these dynamic lines over hand-drawn oil patterns. These early experiments resulted in seminal "visual music" films such as Divertissement Rococo (1951) and Eneri (1953), as well as a series of abstract chromogenic still prints created around 1950 that captured these electronic wave shapes as frozen musical chords. The Ansco Printon chromogenic process which he used for his oscilloscope prints became available to civilians in 1945, and it is conceivable that some of his abstractions were created before 1950.
Hirsh’s completed color oscilloscope photographs circa 1950 predate the earliest dated Ben Laposky Oscillon prints from 1952, as well as Laposky’s first Oscillon exhibition in 1953. By 1952, before Laposky’s first Oscillon exhibition in 1953, Hirsh had already presented oscilloscope-based art to an international festival audience. Laposky subsequently made oscilloscope photography a sustained and widely exhibited practice. Hirsh instead absorbed oscilloscope traces into a broader artistic language of photography, film, color, and optical montage. Laposky’s focused practice became better known, while Hirsh’s earlier finished works remained largely outside public view.
Hirsh died suddenly in Paris in November 1961 at age 49 from a heart attack. French police impounded his estate, resulting in the loss of many original prints and film reels. His surviving artworks are held today by museums and a small number of private collections.
Exhibitions
Lifetime presentations
- 1952 - Edinburgh International Film Festival – Sixth Edinburgh International Film Festival. Hirsh’s Divertissement Rococo was screened only a year after its creation. Contemporary distribution notes describe it as an abstract film composed entirely of oscilloscope and other moving artificial patterns, assembled through optical superimposition and color. See Hertzmann catalogue in the Library and Center for Visual Music filmography.
- 1952-53 San Francisco Museum of Art – Art in Cinema. Hirsh’s Come Closer was presented through the museum’s historic experimental-film program. The film combines complex oscilloscope patterns in multiple simultaneous fields using split-screen and optical-printing techniques. SFMOMA history of Art in Cinema and Center for Visual Music filmography.
- 1954 - California State Exposition – Eneri. The film, in which layered oscilloscope patterns move to African drumming, received first prize. The award demonstrates contemporary recognition of Hirsh’s electronic visual music rather than its purely posthumous rediscovery. Hertzmann catalogue in the Library and Center for Visual Music filmography.
- 1959 - Morrison Planetarium – Vortex 5. A surviving presentation reel contains brief black-and-white oscilloscope patterns by Hirsh, drawn from raw footage he supplied to Jordan Belson. This was incorporated material rather than a standalone Hirsh film, but it provides another documented lifetime presentation of his electronic imagery. Center for Visual Music filmography.
- 1960 - Melbourne International Film Festival – Divertissement Rococo. The festival presented Hirsh’s film as work in a new genre employing electronic and other artificial devices to generate abstract form and motion. Official MIFF archive.
- 1960 - Louvre, Pavillon de Marsan – Retrospective Hy Hirsh. A film retrospective held one year before Hirsh’s death demonstrates that his experimental cinema had achieved institutional recognition during his lifetime. The surviving chronology documents the event, although its complete program has not yet been located. Hertzmann catalogue in the Library.
Later exhibitions of the oscilloscope photographs
- 2010-11 - Princeton University Art Museum - Midcentury Princeton displayed its ca. 1950 chromogenic abstraction, accession 2008-47 from October 23, 2010 until February 20, 2011. Object record with exhibition history and exhibition page.
- 2013-14 - Amon Carter Museum of American Art - Color! American Photography Transformed This included the museum’s unique ca. 1950 dye-coupler print, accession P2008.2, bearing estate inventory 4841. This is particularly relevant because 4841 was the cover image of the Paul Hertzmann catalogue in this collection. Amon Carter object and exhibition record. Exhibition ran October 5, 2013 - January 5, 2014.
- 2024 - J. Paul Getty Museum - Abstracted Light: Experimental Photography The exhibition which ran August 20 - November 24, 2024 included Hirsh’s Untitled, ca. 1950, an Ansco Printon chromogenic print, accession 2013.63, estate inventory 4830. Getty presented it in an exhibition devoted to experimental light exposures and the interplay between still photography and experimental film. This is the strongest museum context for understanding the print as an electronic/light-based abstraction. Getty exhibition and object record.
- 2025 - Rijksmuseum - American Photography The Rijksmuseum displayed its Untitled (Abstraction), ca. 1950, chromogenic print, accession RP-F-2019-161. The museum featured Hirsh under “Pioneering experiments,” describing his experiments with transparency, depth, light and “vibrations.” Official Rijksmuseum feature and exhibition announcement. The exhibition ran February 7 - June 9, 2025.
In the library
3 items



In the Journal
![Hy Hirsh, Untitled [Color Abstraction], circa 1950: turquoise loops, a blue disk, magenta bands and a white diagonal waveform against black.](https://cdn.sanity.io/images/0diin6kb/production/430d24c5338fbcb22ac4285797381a40897073f9-579x730.jpg?w=1200&fit=max&auto=format&q=85)
![Hy Hirsh, Untitled [Color Abstraction], circa 1950. Color photograph.](https://cdn.sanity.io/images/0diin6kb/production/500b6c49ffd73e31a063b90b9bb155c714309fd4-3383x2709.png?w=1200&fit=max&auto=format&q=85)
![Hy Hirsh, Untitled [Color Abstraction], circa 1950: pale pink rounded forms crossed by red bands above undulating blue-violet waves on a dark field.](https://cdn.sanity.io/images/0diin6kb/production/84342189be6e0cd314b21d123858274de908fe0b-2275x1805.jpg?w=1200&fit=max&auto=format&q=85)